Concrete vs clay tile
| Concrete tile | Clay tile | |
|---|---|---|
| Look | Wide range of profiles and colors | Traditional Spanish and Mediterranean look, color through the tile |
| Weight | Heavy | Heavy, often a little lighter than concrete |
| Color | Can fade over time | Holds its color |
| Cost | Lower | Higher |
Both are heavy, so the roof structure has to be designed for tile. Switching from shingle to tile on an existing home may need an engineer's review.
The underlayment does the real work
Tile sheds most of the rain, but water does get under it. The underlayment beneath the tile is what actually keeps the house dry. That is why a tile roof with intact tiles can still leak: the underlayment has worn out. On many older tile roofs, replacing the underlayment is the real fix.
How tile is attached
Florida tile roofs are attached with roof tile adhesive (foam), mechanical fasteners, or both, following the tile manufacturer's tested installation and the Florida Building Code for your wind zone. The right method depends on the tile, the roof and the design wind speed.
Tile roof repair
- Broken and cracked tile. From foot traffic, falling limbs or storms. We replace damaged tiles with matching profile and color where available.
- Slipped tile. Tiles that have come loose and slid. We reset and re-secure them.
- Ridge and hip caps. Loose or cracked caps let water in at the ridge.
- Flashing. Valleys, walls and penetrations.
- Underlayment. When it has failed, tile is removed, the underlayment replaced and the tile reinstalled or replaced.
Please do not walk on a tile roof. Tiles crack easily under foot, and a cracked tile is how many tile leaks start.
Repair, re-underlayment or replacement?
On an older tile roof, three options are usually on the table. A repair fixes a specific problem: a few broken tiles, a ridge cap or a flashing leak. A re-underlayment, sometimes called a tile lift and relay, removes the tile, replaces the worn underlayment and puts the good tile back. A full replacement starts over with new tile. Which one makes sense depends on how much tile is still sound, whether matching tile is available and how much of the roof is affected. We look at all three and tell you plainly.
Tile roof replacement
- Estimate We inspect the tile, underlayment and decking and tell you whether repair, re-underlayment or full replacement makes sense.
- Written price and tile selection You choose the tile; we put scope and price in writing.
- Permit We pull the permit.
- Install Tear-off, deck repair, underlayment, flashing and tile installation.
- Final inspection The building department inspects and the permit is closed.
Pricing
Tile type, roof size, underlayment and how many tiles can be reused all change the price. Every roof is priced after we look at it, and you get a written estimate, usually within 24 hours. See metal vs shingle vs tile. Financing is available.


Common questions
Why does my tile roof leak if the tiles look fine?
Tile sheds most of the water, but the underlayment beneath it is the real waterproofing. When the underlayment wears out, the roof leaks even with intact tile.
Can you replace just the underlayment and reuse my tile?
Sometimes. It depends on the tile's condition and whether enough can be removed without breaking. We will look and tell you whether reuse makes sense.
Can you match my broken tiles?
We look for matching profile and color. Older tiles can be hard to match exactly; we may pull matching tiles from a less visible area and use the new ones there.
Should I walk on my tile roof?
No. Tiles crack easily under foot. Leave it to a roofer who knows where to step.
