Florida certified roofing contractor FL license CCC1331274 Based in Tampa Bay, serving homeowners and builders across Florida (813) 513-2516Hablamos español

Metal vs shingle vs tile roofs in Florida: a 2026 Tampa Bay comparison

Three roof types cover most homes in Tampa Bay. Each one fits a different house, budget and plan for how long you'll stay. Here's how they compare, so you can walk into an estimate knowing what to ask.

Updated November 3, 2026 · EBM Roofing Enterprises, license CCC1331274

When a roof wears out, most Tampa Bay homeowners choose between three types: architectural asphalt shingle, metal and tile. All three can be installed to the Florida Building Code and all three can be a good roof. The right one depends on your house, your HOA, your budget and how long you plan to own the home.

The short version

Architectural shingleMetalConcrete or clay tile
Up-front costLowestHigher than shingleHigher than shingle
LifespanShortest of the three in Florida sunLongLong, with the underlayment the part that wears
WeightLightLightestHeaviest
HeatAbsorbs heat, more so in dark colorsLight, coated panels reflect sunMass and air space slow heat gain
RepairsSimple and commonLess frequent, but need a crew experienced with metalBroken tiles need matching; walking on tile can crack it
LookFits most homesCoastal, modern and farmhouseSpanish and Mediterranean

Metal

Metal costs more up front than shingle, and it gives a lot back over the life of the house. For owners who plan to stay, it is the roof we recommend most often.

  • Long life. A well-installed metal roof generally outlasts asphalt shingles by a wide margin.
  • Wind. The metal systems we install carry Florida Product Approval for high-wind zones, and standing seam panels have no exposed fasteners on the face of the roof.
  • Heat. Light-colored, coated panels reflect sunlight, which helps keep attics cooler in a Tampa summer.
  • Weight. Metal is the lightest of the three, so it works on almost any home without structural changes.
  • Near salt water. On homes close to the coast, ask about panel material and coatings rated for salt air.

Most of the metal we install on homes is standing seam. Exposed-fastener panels cost less and suit porches, outbuildings and some budget projects. See metal roofing for how the two compare.

Architectural shingle

Shingle is still the most common roof on Tampa Bay homes, and for good reason. It costs the least up front, it comes in colors that fit almost any HOA, and repairs are quick. The trade-off is lifespan: Florida's sun, heat and storms wear shingles faster than metal or tile.

We install shingles from GAF, IKO, Owens Corning and CertainTeed. If you plan to sell in the next several years or need to keep the project budget down, shingle is often the right call. See shingle roof replacement.

Tile

Concrete and clay tile give a home the classic Florida look and last a long time. The tile itself often outlives the underlayment beneath it, so many older tile roofs need new underlayment while the tiles are still in good shape.

Tile is heavy. Going from shingle to tile can mean checking the roof framing first. Tile can also crack under foot traffic, so repairs take care. See tile roofing.

Questions to ask before you choose

  • How long will you own the home? The longer you stay, the more a long-life roof pays you back.
  • What does your HOA allow? Many associations limit roof types and colors. Check before you fall in love with a color.
  • What will your insurer credit? Ask your agent how roof type, age and the wind mitigation form affect your premium.
  • What's under the roof? Every replacement should cover decking condition, underlayment and roof-to-wall connections, not just the surface material.

Why we don't post prices

Material prices change often, and no two roofs are alike. Size, pitch, layers to tear off and decking condition all move the number. Instead of a price list that's out of date next month, we look at your roof and give you a written estimate, usually within 24 hours. Financing is available. See roof financing.

Common questions

Which roof lasts longest in Florida?

A well-installed metal roof or a tile roof generally lasts much longer than an asphalt shingle roof. Sun, heat and storms are hard on shingles, so they need replacing sooner. How long any roof lasts depends on the installation, the underlayment, ventilation and how the roof is maintained.

Is a metal roof louder in the rain?

On a home, metal panels go over solid decking and underlayment, and the attic and insulation sit between the roof and the rooms below. Most homeowners find rain noise is close to what they had before.

Can I switch from shingle to tile or metal?

Switching to metal is usually simple because metal is light. Switching to tile adds a lot of weight, so the roof framing may need to be checked first. Many HOAs also limit which roof types and colors are allowed, so check your association's rules early.

Why don't you list prices?

Material prices move often, and every roof is different in size, pitch, layers and decking condition. We price each roof after we look at it, and you get a written estimate, usually within 24 hours of the visit.

Related

Get a free estimate on your roof

Tell us about the project and we'll set up a time to look at it. Builders can send plans.

Call Free estimate